Judicial Watch • U.S. Pours Millions Into Failing Black Colleges, Breaks New Student Loan Rules

U.S. Pours Millions Into Failing Black Colleges, Breaks New Student Loan Rules

U.S. Pours Millions Into Failing Black Colleges, Breaks New Student Loan Rules

MAY 14, 2014

The federal government violates its own student loan rules and wastes hundreds of millions of dollars to subsidize perpetually failing black colleges, including the alma mater of pop star Michael Jackson’s criminally-convicted doctor, a Judicial Watch investigation has found.

The institutions are known as Historically Black Colleges and Universities (HBCU) and JW’s probe has uncovered documents that show American taxpayers are being forced to fund them even when their accreditation has been stripped, they have dismal graduation rates and rank among the nation’s worst medical schools. For instance, Meharry Medical College (where the late Jackson’s physician, Conrad Murray, got his degree) is renowned for producing an alarming number of inept doctors along with third-world institutions like Manila Central University in the Philippines and the Autonomous University of Guadalajara in Mexico, according to records obtained by JW.

Yet the government continues giving it—and other troubled black colleges—large sums of money in the form of low-interest “loans” that are usually defaulted. This is done through the Historically Black College and University Capital Financing Program and it’s proven to be a massive boondoggle. Obtained from a variety of government sources—including the U.S. Treasury and the Department of Education—the files accessed by JW show that the scandalous investment is not only fleecing taxpayers, it’s also breaking rules created by the Obama administration under a 2010 measure that replaced student loans by private lenders with direct loans by the U.S. government.

Once its own money was in the game, the government decided that student loan lending rules were too loose and default rates were too high. In October 2011, the Department of Education quietly changed underwriting criteria for the transactions, known as PLUS student loans. Those criteria are still pretty low (“prospective borrowers can’t have any current accounts more than 90 days delinquent, or any foreclosures, bankruptcies, tax liens, wage garnishments or defaults within the past five years. But the department doesn’t look at prospective borrowers’ incomes or their current debt load, meaning that poor borrowers with little or no credit history can be approved”), but still resulted in a 10% increase in the denial rate.

Historically black colleges and universities were most adversely impacted by the new credit standards and HBCU officials as well as African American community leaders lobbied the Education Department to change the standards. Education Secretary Arne Duncan apologized about the unintended effect on black colleges but publicly maintained that “our department is required to carry out the law as it was designed to protect parents and taxpayers against unaffordable loans.” Duncan did admit that that the process could have been handled better and that internal and external communications were “poor,” according to a mainstream newspaper.

Behind the scenes his agency quickly circumvented those “laws to protect parents and taxpayers.” In fact, Duncan sent a letter to the Congressional Black Caucus regarding the impact that the new loan rules were having on HBCUs stating that the Department had “used [its] authority to consider ‘extenuating circumstances’ as a method to provide immediate relief for many students, which allowed previous PLUS loan recipients and applicants whose adverse credit determinations were based on a ‘de minimis’ amount of debt to obtain a loan through the reconsideration process.”

The agency has used the accommodation to provide near-blanket approvals for PLUS loan applications from previous recipients, according to the records obtained by JW. This academic year, about a third of the applicants from historically black colleges denied this year were eligible to appeal. Of those, 38 percent, or just over 8,000 applicants, filed for reconsideration. Virtually all of them—98.5 percent—were then approved for a PLUS loan, the records show.

So why does the government continue pouring enormous sums of money into these failing institutions that often can’t even keep their accreditation? The only explanation JW could find among the droves of government records is the Obama administration’s determination of “the importance of HBCUs as a national resource.”

Sign Up for Updates!


Read more about

© 2010-2014 Judicial Watch, Inc. All Rights Reserved.

  • Fedup

    Affirmative Action was thrown out by the Supreme Court! I for one am dam tired of being treated like a second class check Citizen since these two pieces of shit started living in the White House!

  • CopperDollar

    Why is the government in the student loan business?

  • Mark 2112

    well considering everything these days is racist, why not? ;)

  • Anonymous

    Does anyone have a list of the Historically White Colleges and Universities or the Historically Asian Colleges and Universities?

  • ** Defiant Soul **

    I’m ok with that.

  • Mark 2112

    that would be racist.

  • ** Defiant Soul **

    Maybe I’m uninformed, but, can you give me the name of one all white college?

  • Ayatollah Obama Bin Soetero

    Not much of a return on investment there.

  • Hope is not a battle plan

    They’re too black to fail
    Where will our struggling black youth go to get education “their way”?

  • Ultracon

    disgusting ineptitude by our “laaaaawmakers”……. what the H else is new?

  • http://www.tempeteaparty.org Lee Reynolds

    The difference is not between the races, but between the kinds of students these schools attract, and the kinds of students that ordinary schools appeal to. 60 years ago, these schools were the only places that most black people could attend. The best and brightest of black America went to these schools.

    Today, the best and brightest of black America go to the same universities as the best and brightest from every other ethnic group. These schools now get the dregs who aren’t bright enough to go to the mainstream universities. These schools also get all of the people with a chip on their shoulder who think by going to a black school they’re somehow sticking it to whitey. Not exactly a high achieving group of people either way.

    The only option these schools have, if they are to survive and prosper as places of learning, is to work on attracting students of every creed and color.

    As for the lowering of standards for firemen and policemen, this is just a back-door quota system. Some leftarded bureaucrat thinks there aren’t enough black firemen or policemen, so they lower the standards rather than work on legitimate recruitment of qualified candidates.

  • David_Smith

    The elephant in the room, of course, is that this is extremely racist. Imagine if the situation were reversed and the government was supporting all white colleges and allowing them to default in this way.

  • Elfego

    Affirmative Action still alive and well.

  • mythenjoseph

    So explain to me again there is no difference between the races? Why do they lower thresholds for police and fire testing for minorities? Must be that damned whitey keepin’ em’ down again.