Skip to content

Judicial Watch • 2011 mrc-kagan-docs

2011 mrc-kagan-docs

2011 mrc-kagan-docs

Page 1: 2011 mrc-kagan-docs

Category:Obtained Document

Number of Pages:24

Date Created:April 27, 2011

Date Uploaded to the Library:July 30, 2013

Tags:issues, edwin, currie, person, Assistant, subject, Civil, health, original, Attorney, meeting, Joseph, michael, thomas, department, court, EPA, IRS, ICE


File Scanned for Malware

Donate now to keep these documents public!

  • demand_answers

See Generated Text   ˅

Autogenerated text from PDF

FW: Health Care Defense Page.I ofl 
Kagan, Elena 
From: Kagan, Elena 
Sent: Friday, JanuaryOS, 2010 :01 
To: Katya!, Neal  
Subject: Re: Health Care Defense 

You should It. 
From: Katya!, Neal 
To: Kagan, Elena 
Sent: Fri-Jan 10:57:38 2010 
Subject:FW: Health Care Defen5e happy this you are with ii. Otherwise would the natural person. both 
Frvm1 Hauck, Brian 
Sant; Frltfay, January 08, 2010 10:54 PiM 

Tot Katypl; Neal 
Subjectt Healtb Caro Defense Neal -Tom wants put together group get thinking about how defend ageinsl inevitable challenges the health care proposals that are pending, and hoped that OSG could participate. Could you figure out the rioht person people for lhat? More merrier. hoping meet next week can.  

Thanks, 

Brian 

Sent: 
Friday, January 08, 2010 10:68 

To: Kagan, :lena Subject: FW: Health Care Defense happy this you are with Otherwise would the natural parson. both 
Frotn: To;" 
Haucki Brian Friday, January 08, 2010 10:54 
Kalyal, Neal Health care DefeASe Neal -Tom wants put together group get thinking about how defend against Inevitable challe,nges the heallh care proposals that are pending, and hoped that OSG could participate. Could you,figure out the right person people for that? More the merrier. hoping meet next week can. 
Thanks, 
Brian 

Health Care Page 
Kagan, Elena 
From:  Katya!, Neal  
Sent:  Thursday, March 18, 2010 1:37  
To:  Perrelli, Thomas  
Cc:  Kagan, Elena  

Subject: RE: Health Care 
Tom, was just looking the draft complaint Landmark Legal Foundation. clearly written filed when the House approves the reconciliation bill and before the President signs it. See paras 15-17. 
Also para says the action being brought before signed President that expectations regularity can asserted, etc. such, could court very very soon. 
 light this, for what worth, advice haven't discussed this with Elena but cc'in her here would that start assembling response,  llilllillso that have ready go. They obviously have their piece ready go, and think it'd great are ahead the ball game here. 
From: Perrelli, Thomas Sent: Wednesday, March 17, 2010 9:25 To: Katya!, Neal Subject: Re: Health Care 
Neal tabled when things looked bleak, but should it. I'll get something together the next week. 
From: Katya Neal To: Perrelli; Thomas Sent: Wed Mar 09:17:13 2010 Subject: Health Care 
Tom, recall you were going set group deal with the inevitable challenges this legislation. Now that this may coming back, wanted circle back and see you still are developing such litigation group. Thanks, 
Health care litigation meeting Page of! 
Kagan, Elena 
From: Katyal, Neal 
Sent: Sunday, March 21, 2010 6:19 
To: Kagan, Elena 
Subject: Fw: Health care lltlgatlon.maatlng 

This the first I've heard this. think you should. go, no? will, regardless, but feel like this litigation
singular importance. 
From: Perrelli, ThomasJ. 
To: Gershengorn, Ian (CIV); Brinkmann, Beth (CIV); West, Tony (CIV); Martinez, Brian (CIV); Adlga, Mala; 
Gerra, Joseph R.; Delery, Stuart (ODAG); Cedarbaum, Jonathan; Golder, Chad (ODAG); Monaco, Lisa (ODAG); Katyal, Neal Cc: Gunn, Currie (SMO); Guerr;i Joseph Sent: Sun Mar 2118:11:12 2010 Subject: Health care litigation mlll!tlng 
All sounds like can meet with some the health care policy team tomorrow 4to help pref)are for litlgatlon. It.has .over there. Can folks send the waves info (full name, SSN, oOB) 
everyone that should attend soon possible? wants tonight, possible. know won't 
get everyone's tonight. 
Also, need think about the key Issues/questions for the agenda. iny list/ but know there are others. Tony/Ian/Beth can CIV flesh out what discuss? 
Jonathan and OLC may have some ideas well. 
Thanks 
Tom 
Health care litigationmeeting Page of! 
Kagan, Elena 
From: Kagan, Elena Sant: Sunday, March 21, 2010 6:20 To: Katyal, Neal Subject: Re.: Health care litigation meeting 
Whafs your phone number? 
From: Katyal, Neal 
To: Kagan, Elena 
Sent: Sun Mar 2118:18:45 2010 
st.ibject: Fw: Health care litigation meeting 
This the first I've heard this. think you should go, no? wilt, regardless, but feel like this litigation singular Importance. 
From: Perrelli, Thomas To: Gershengorn, Ian (CIV}; Brinkmann, Beth (CIV); West, Tony (CIV); Martinez, Brian (CIV); Adiga, Mala; 
Guerra, Joseph R.; Delery, Stuart (ODAG); Cedarbaum, Jonathan; Golder, Chad (ODAG); Monaco, Lisa 
(ODAG); Katyal, Neal 
Cc: Gunn; Currie (SMO)i Guerra, Joseph 
Sent: Sun Mar 18: 11: 2010 
Subject: Health care litigation meeting 
All . sounds like can meehvlth some the health care policy team tomorrow 4to help prepare for litigation. has over there. Can folks send the waves Info (full name, SSN, DOB) everyone that should attend as. soon possible? wants tonight, possible. know won't get everyone's tonight. 
Also; need think about the key Issues/questions for the agenda. (b) (5) ops list, but know there are others. Tony/Ian/Beth --can CIV flesh out what feel like weneed discuss? Jonatnan and OLC may have some Ideas well. 
thanks! 
Tom 
Health care litigation meeting Page 
Kagan, Elena 
From: Katya!, Neal 
Sent: Sunday, Maroh 21, 2010 6:22 
To: Kagan, Elena 
Subject: Re: Health care lltlgatlon meeting 

MIDWll 
From: Kagan, Elena 
To: Katya!, Neal. 
Sent: Sun Mar 2118:19:46 2010 
Subject: Re: Health care litigation meeting 
What's your phone number? 
From: Kacyal, Neal To: Kagan, Elena Sent sun Mar 2118:18:45 2010 subject: Fw: Health care litigation meeting 
This the first I've heard this. think you should go, no? will, regardless, but feel like this litigation. singular importance. 
From: Perrelli, Thomas 
To:. Gersheagom, Ian (CIV); Brinkmann, Beth (CIV); West, Tony (CIV); Martinez, Brian (CIV); Adlga, Mala; 
Guerra, Joseph R.; Delery, Stuart (ODAG); Cedarbaum, Jonathan; Golder, Chad (ODAG); Monaco, Lisa 
(ODAG); Katya!, Neal 
Cc: Gunn, Currie (SMO); Guerra, .Joseph 
sent: Sun Mar 2118:11:12 2010 


 
Subject: Health care litigation meeting 
All- sounds like we. can meet with some the health care policy team tomorrow help prepare for litigation. has overthere. Can folks send the waves info (full name; SSN, DOB) everyonethat should attend soon possible? wants tonight, possible. know won't
 
get everyone's tonight. 

Also, need think about the key issues/questions for the agenda. ops list, butl know there are others. Tony/Ian/Beth --can CIV flesh out what feel lilie need discuss? Jonathan and OLC may !iave some Ideas as. well. 
Thanks 
Tom 
Kagan, Elena 
From: Oreeben, Michael. Sent: Wednesday, March 24, 2010 2:31 To: Kagan, Elena; Kneedler, Edwin Subject: Fw; Health care challenges 
Elena and Ed, the message below, several USAs volunteered that they hoped that Our. office wOuld invOlved Structuring the 9overnment1a defense health care. For all know, are involved. Just wanted pass this on. 
Thanks, 
Michael 
-----Ori9inal Messa9e ----
FrQm: Dreeb_en,R

Michael "ro: Brinkmann, Beth (CIV)
Sent: Wed Mar 24. 125: 2010 
Subject: Health care challenges Beth, spoke the Attorney1s conference today TeIDpe and sv6ral them came afterwards ask how the Department coordinating responses the state 
lawsuits. They d "like know what anything they should aay publicly in response and 
equally important who should -they comTnuniate with about defendin,g these auita. aseume 
that Civil goin9 take the leaain the defense these cases, no? there task 
dorce lead person whom should refer the USAs? haven't already done so, 
seems that (the Department} should take the initiative contact the USAs the 
districts whe;J:e states have sue.d let them know what the process and lines of 
:cesponsibility will be. apologies "if this has already been done, has, some USAs 
haven't gotten the word. 
Michael 
Kagan, Elena 
From: Dreeben, Michael Sent: Wednesday, March 24, 2010 2:32 To: Kagan, Elena; Kneedler, Edwin Subject: Fw: Health care challenges  
Beth's response. 
-----Original Message From: Brinkmann, Beth .(CIV) To: Dreeben, Michael Sent: Wed Mar 14:29:59 2010 
Subject: RE: Heal.th care challenges 
Michael, 
Ye"s1 Ton, Ian and had nationwide conference call esterday with the Civil Chiefs.
memo also went out the day before forwarding right after this. Let1s discuss 

you have ideas about what more do. 
Beth 
-----Original Message---
From: Dreeben, Michael-R 
Sent: wectnesday, March 24, 2010 2:6 
'To: Brinkmann, Beth (CIV) 
SUbject: Health eare challenges Beth, :Elp.oke the Attorney1s conference today Tempe and several them came afterwards ask how-the l:>epa-rtment coordinating responses the sta-te lawsuits. They'd like know what .if anything they should say publicly response and equally important who should they communicate" with about defending these suita. asaunte that Civil going.to take the lead the defense these cases1 no? there task dorce lead person 'whom should refer the USAs? havent already done so, seemS that-we (the Department) should take the initiative to.contact the USAs the districts where states have sued let them know what the process and lines responsibility will be. apologies this has already been don:e. has1 some USAs
 
haven1t gotten the word 
Michael 
Kagan, Elena 
From: breeben, Michael Sent: Wednesday, March 24, 201 2:32 To: Kagan, Elena; Kneedler, .Edwin Subject: Fw: Health care challenges 
More. 
---"-Original Message ----From: Brinkmann, Beth CIV) To: Dreeben, Michael 'sent: .Wed Mar 24. 14:29:59 2010 Subject: RE Healtheare challenges 
Michael 
Yea, Ton,-Ian and had natiowide conference call yesterday with the Civil chiefs. memo also went out the day before. forwadig right after this Let dis you have ideas about what more do. 
 
Beth 
-----Original Message--." -From Dreeben Michael 
Sent: Wednesday, March 24, 2011> 2:26  
To: Brinl