Skip to content

Judicial Watch, Inc. is a conservative, non-partisan educational foundation, which promotes transparency, accountability and integrity in government, politics and the law.

Judicial Watch, Inc. is a conservative, non-partisan educational foundation, which promotes transparency, accountability and integrity in government, politics and the law.

Because no one
is above the law!

Donate

Corruption Chronicles

Judge Rules Against State’s Secrecy

In a victory for open government advocates, a Florida judge has ruled that public officials improperly withheld information from a vendor that accused a state agency of holding secret, closed-door meetings.

The vendor, MHM Correctional Services, provides mental health care to more than 15,000 inmates in a dozen south Florida prisons and wants to extend its 2 ½-year contract. The state’s Department of Corrections wants to replace MHM with a vendor that would charge taxpayers $5.5 million more for the same service.

MHM filed a lawsuit against the state accusing it of illegally favoring a competitor and of holding “secret” and “closed-door” talks with the firm. The complaint points out that the department’s secret negotiations violate its own internal procedures and flaunt the state’s procurement process and inexplicable insistence on wasting $5 million in public funds. 

The ousted vendor further alleged that the state violated its open records law—known as the Sunshine Law—by omitting electronic mails related to the case.

In-house counsel defending the corrections department in court argued that Florida’s Sunshine Law doesn’t apply to state purchasing committees. 

However, a judge in Tallahassee slammed the argument this week, ruling that the Florida Department of Corrections did in fact improperly withhold public records. ”The court has conducted an in-camera inspection of the document containing the e-mail stream and has determined that it is not exempt…” Circuit Judge Kevin Davey wrote in his opinion.

[Update – Early reports indicated that Florida Attorney General Bill McCollum was defending the Corrections Department, but that was incorrect and our blog entry has been updated appropriately.]