Skip to content

Judicial Watch • JW v State CREW production 00574

JW v State CREW production 00574

JW v State CREW production 00574

Page 1: JW v State CREW production 00574

Category:

Number of Pages:113

Date Created:August 29, 2016

Date Uploaded to the Library:September 15, 2016

Tags:Ludlam, volunteers, Corps, peace, volunteer, CREW, 00574, unclassif, Amman, Vaughn, unclass, Exemption, summary, Karen, mummy, release, AGENCY, ACLU, unclassified, production, FBI, FOIA, EPA, IRS, ICE, CIA


File Scanned for Malware

Donate now to keep these documents public!


See Generated Text   ∨

Autogenerated text from PDF

einad airlodreerusen the Foih
Urtttetl States Department Slzlle
Washington. 0.0 20520
Case No: F72016701402
Segmenl: L-0001; L-0
Michael Bekeshtr
423 Third Street, sew. AUG
Suite 800
Washington, 20024
Dear Mr. Bcknsha:
lrerer you l) our letter dulad July 29: 2015, regarding the release material under Freedom erlnfomtnuon Acl {Ihc FOIA s.c. 552. The seureh the
Offim (If the legal Atlyrser has been completed and rcsullzd the retrieval of27
documents responsive your request Arrer reviewing these documcllls, have
deterrmned that may released full.10 may released pan, and must wtmhcld full.
All enclosure explains the FOIA exemptions and other grounds fnr withholding
material Where have made excisions, the applicable exemptions are marked the document. The tour documents withheld full done under FOIA
Excmplion 552(u)(5). All non-exempt material that reasonably
seyegnble from the exempt material has been rclmwcd. All role-used minerml
eneloserl. thl keep you informed your case progresses. you have any questions,
please conlacl Federal ngmmh Atrorney James BIL-Hard (202) 30577632.
Please refer the associated casc ntrmuer, FVZUISVOMOZ. and Die civil netinn mrnrher, rcv700574, :lll eornrrrunieatron regarding rltrs caser
Sinoercly,
Eric rein, Acling CD- 51mm lutermatien Programs and Serytees
Enclosulcs: Slated
The; Freedom Inlovma Ac! use 552}
ram Examplmns
(um) MlNInlmng speamcsny numurizn cran Emma Older [Muesl ovnahona
wens. rang pom. nrupulyc assmad, E0. ussa mama. immune:
Inc mnmng cussmum calegmes Mnusny guns sysums. amperalians
4(a) Fnrmgn governmenl Warm-Ill) nlul gcnm ammlms snumcs melhbds. cryplmcgy ang Ielax ons szxgnacimnes onne US. Includmg denlnl sauces Suum becnnq rd, emnmric matters Ielaling mam sewmy
mdudmg nanny: agamsumnsn-u onl! lemmm Gwcmmcm yruglams saveguamln] nmm malma mamas am) anzml games nvsyllemx. msxeuauons Innssxnmms. pluiccls.
glans. pmmmn swims Making nsHonnl sleulizy, mdu mam
agalnsl Itansnlmne xenonsm
mm) nlormi waannngalmass deslmcl
(um) Rnhle smmy mme vnxemsl persnnrm] and practices agency
(hm) Sveu caly uxempxeu Immmsmsm Stan (cine! man use 552). lcreumme
mmsx Aim: Expnn CnmmlMl, use 27mm Cenlnl unleumsm Agency was use 4mm)
EXPORT awn Adminixwlinn I)! me. ADD. use 1mm
fSA Farelgn Semenmnm uscawu aoa lmmlgminn and Naworuhly use 1mm
wow cums Semen-mm 5:: 505, usc
(am Punxsgwmmsnnsl Ind: scum Gamma/um nanual mmmw Mom pglsnn
{0K5} Mange/Ky min-agency wmmumcauuns lnrmmw pan In: blmllvu wows; nnumnydmm pmnege, aha/My work pludud
mun) Imonnsusn Ihal wuul wnwlutl clamy unwinanled invasion umersonal pmecy Innsmnsn mmpueu her law unlamnunl Dumas mm, mam wim enlwmmnnl WumL-mng:
(3} mm. Dam of. laxrlnil minimum unwanamed mason npersunm pmazy
(n. nisclase :anmemm sums
LE) msdnw Imcs galhn techniques angel lie nnym ivdual Prlpaw to! govern-mu agency regulating supervising {manual insmulions
(any) swam: geopnvmw mmmalnn sna zla. nc maul. wncemmn wens
Omar Grounds luv Wlmhuldlng Mama: nut lusponslve FelAn-qucsL excised Mmme Agviemenl :71 request
uNcmssmEu uepanmenms CaseN F201su1 Doc 005104322 Dale omzwmp
nzmai gym nuarou mm:
Case No.: F-zoly zsx ASE ruLQ
1%;me Wuismamx
won Eye NW. Sun: 450
Wuhingmn. zuous
DearMs Wewsmmm
1mm ynuv lemrdzlzd Dcmmbar 21);; Nquus ngmdar ymssuus-
nflh: Fleednm armromauumu: mu: srmsc Szcrian.552) and/or
Privacy Auumc susc Swim. 552 mmlease ornamhwmm
mmuined the Daparungm sum,
ThnDcpzmmrufSIale mn-numw ofnuurd iyncmi; entglfmiy
Policy Record Fil: auwmltw
subsunuvc {amp pnlwy duwmwl: Add runny.
Depnmnem anthomigl Service pasts aigmadmunmm 1):: ll1=ir
apemubns.1nlnmahnn ibuubth: Depn tqhd mlssiapm mctianx iLi individualburuus and ces. wall $0! pails 117mm Mme www. sum gov Gmmmu uul blishad Govcmmcnl nling 0mg: n_nd will most hmneg.
am. [he 5anch mm. nfyunr mqugc. whammy; file: um: lncs rmnnnhly may maintain rpmwive words. 15mm
lnrurmumn Rum-M Managungnlg meExgml Sccmu hfammion
Ruaumcs angancm omoc, Excculivc szcmnms
Cal-respondent: and Round; nus: lcs unmhmtbypmlqasmnal
employaes fnuuhar Wm. dun! mutants and mganimim, and mtnrds
mpunsiv! your veqmsr we. located,
UNCLASSIF DEDanmenlulSlate oaseNo F-2D1M14D2 DoCNn 005104322 Dam owa/zms
UNCLASSWED Depanmeninis CassNa F20 DncNu cnaimzzz Daie 05/29/2015
magma. Foil bickguun may helpful in: you know maimemgu than
Scumnryran: namionailymsmiliad LhaDupamnnnl Vin e-muil:
Huwzvcx. mu: mpssagss are ransminmi dummy =-mzil address max cayabic receiving {him uno aning z-rnnil
IccounL
hey the mpanmems response your tonnes! more positive.
Phuc dimi quesiinns cumming massing orywr use the 085::
lnfomutlon mama: and ssmcss. A/GISIIPS, sA-a. Risa-n no. v.3.
Depmmsm orsme, Washingmn. D.C. 1052141 rumor raienhona mime:
(2m) zei-mo,
ifhs D.C, cimiii (Jamar Appuis, Ogiasby ggamcnl om: Ai-mx 920 .0: 9b),,rulea rim mcbni myonsswnsiiimcs
advuic demminsnon, mum muiring agnncy nyiis
xequhsxel our damm nakion iii: Depmeiirdacs muhsv: mom:
mpvnsivc :1an may hzuppulcd wimxr ili ydny the due onhis
lean. Aimwyi mum mini our sisamii effun has squniw
.sun: ynu air mail ofmsmun duisian
Appears shnuld brlddmsiedflo: cruimm. Appizl: Mow.P and, i-Ja Awesls
emces,NGisriPS/PPIJ-.c. metiiian, SA-z, u.s.mpmmr 5mg,
Wuhingwn,D:C. 2051mm wpy anhsmpmmerigjm mudum mum. Muse refer-x0 ans: cunlrul numw sumsbnvcin
mnaspoudznc: mnuemingmis can.
Sinweiy, 4.4:; Sheryl WKHIL. mum nvo nfumIioni mgmmijndISmlc
Enclosure: sum
m5: Casio-1322 Daie UB/ZSIZWE
uNcussmEu U.S.Depanment015(ate CaseNn.F-2mE-D14D2 Dar. 005104327 Dam uarzsnme
gm: Vain nuarou
m... smmsmm
5m, MM, my) 701311.12
sum. ran Raquulr-wudo smgwuby 1012-4095) WW.
cans...
Muchmmsc
wmswo
ammun- UNcmssmm
smmleybd Senmiv: smmww Wm...g 9mm.
nu: uNcussmEo
me: luam saw
5m: man. 20,2011 mum, 63:
5mm: mmmm Human; 09mm
Gene-Hun mnmmmmm May mum.
Eviar umuun
Flcu urmu mum
yvarsmsmu/w
Emmx. valh (mumm. Mnua vaEasmmA auK
mmksm man UNCLASSVHED
UNCLASSIF us. Dspnnmenluislsla Cass F-zmsmduz Dar: cummaz? [me name/2015
uncmssmao nepanmenmvsme CaseNu.F ZDlB D1ADZ Doc caemns Dae name/2016 wmd Va?! nuarou ddlcnsforxespon biliry
CRE andcducsinwlslungton Dumber Ilulmlln: madam Inlnmlunu Pinyin}: 5mm
mssmsnu 5.1):pammorsm,
Wishinyan 205mm
3:: Man hlnma nnm uquut
ma. 0mm
Pursuant maamrmmm (mm), 955mm,
mmm alsnu (Sula) mum mam; mwnsnaui-y and mag (CREW uzuuu dml Shaw lb: numb alumna Munich: Semuly Gianna, whim um: Iwoums idunifuhl: has! ufol mama wnh see-my Clinmn. ldzmi nbw
ulkm whim :m-il mum would perm may
mun! um: xzmmy Plan: MMCREWdoes nmmk mnun mm-q mud=uyzumpl inlumalxon,
Haul. lzsponslve was nyntdlcss 1mm. Mm, physic
manna-ism pasmu plus; mum Illmnitdiy. 170an [nmzwn
mama. suk retards any km, mam aamluc 1m. mm-pa vidmupt, phatag vls yaw pusnwn pumun om: [bl-2mm m1: uzxzmplkem disdmm
cmw mm: pmmdx: wnn nfllmsc damn-amt: 121 Vaughn mFummc 19mm mmnsus. M70972) ynuuthval: ucb donut-mm china amp. wimsul cizm speci nly nnonrdludamun whmhar manrinl umnly am, mar row
fuming Chandra/Sammy 9.11.593 was. 949 (m: Cin 1979! Momm,
Vaughn mu. hunk dasnmuu pmlmn mmrmmud.ml (a.
wIledmg dams may nfsuyplying wash! mummmn Km; a/Junm 2.1 22: m7) mm; Alden)
mihlwldm: may Suppi) unmiv umnn._sp=t1 tdyidlmiiyml
mm; why pamculi: zxtmpunn and numbing tllimi wim ptmwln Mum which may mus (an. gumdom 5pm.: 11.3
Derry/mun- rmusu (11c 1977;)
ImEyeSImnMw.sm-s;wwmbc1m mzaasssyma znzmsnzem mmxzmmmmw
uNCLASS FKED
.Dspmmamofstats cue F-zows-cuuz Doc Naco D2te.DB/2 /201Ei
uNCmSSiFiEn Depgnmzntgisiate Case Frzmsmauz Dun CD51DA755 oaie- E/29IZD1E
engined Dirlud in: Via my.
Fol/i
Mamba iaa mai small: panama nlml mammal aiaamy Exempl
disdnsun, .iisuaaa mummy ugcyhl: mhutmpl punim am: Kamila mains Ste 0511955202), yaw pasxhun damnnl mnuiu wucnmpi
seguAnIS. mas: nun4x=mpk5zpvmnu dispmod mmnghmd lb: documcnl uyzglunn impossible, plwa mi: wiiai aamaa dmmznl mn-uempl. Ind aaa mlluinl aiapmm hmngbmn (k. dawlnznl MudDam Caaimi, 566 26L
aiaawagiaiiiiy musl aim Whh 5am: days: dam! mum iai
:xlmpn ons Vaughn mdu magi aammia Mick, please 5m: mac-nun), mai
aoi Xusb lbl: SWIC pamiaii: Mm: Krox
naany, 015w wdu unu appunvnily vim you whelhnr and in; menu
which quaint: runny-min: modi MIR! nub]: Do} plow: hwiihin
YUM! dudlm Tuwnd adult-s: M51: wnmkm MZWADS-SSSS amid-m: min us. ssziixoxAmiq CREW .2an mini iaaa wound with pmsmg hls qua! iai mm. mica mi: uqaui
comm; Eh: npclmnn: iii: imam guvemmut aaa (mn uru. .aa 5!. enemies iiiaciy
wiii aaainaaii inner undzrsiandmg 1:1:va gnvammmv pmaduus Ihb
pull pnhliz ii. siyiimnnl wly. Muiwvel, mam: primlnly aaa lundmnu
nan-mmtm purpnsuv ssuamxiixuij 23.. MzClzllnn Emlupml
Earhm 5:5 m2, (W: mi. 1937).
Sptn ully, mu: wands at: linly mnlnbvillc yum yum; imam in:
ulumm which Sammy uiaiaa wadmiaisaaiaiamia Envimmunlll momma Aymy
(an), naau Imam: May idw ahk Imus. Rmauy wts nponcd
Adamant-w iacisaa wablisbzd mil mum: oundm mammaai humm,
minding undlrlb: name Rich-rd wiaasaaw whlidymnbmhltm sanmvi Sam Th:
mu. Novuubei (ainrmu App- any mixpnmm aiiaa mums back. funnel Amaaiismmi Carol Brawn, magi mi: mu. CREW seal:
lam naw esp nus Ind mimic in: exmu in: undu-
aicimmaiaaaaasia rum. dummy, and mnmssianu mums, Ind mam imam
mania way thnmmpliu mamam, mm;
anw nun-plum maaamiaa mind undu stain 501(c)(3) immai
Rum Cad: CREW miaaa yin-mum; puhlxcsligbt nub: nmviuu
aiammam airimi: cumin; in: inupiry (has: as- als, cxsw dtdiaud
mama dmcnsm iniiauuiai voice gnvzmmgm Siam aaa uia gamaiaem
UNcLAssIFiED nepanmemcismia Case F7201 u1402 Doc 005104755 Dais owmma
uNCLASSlFlED Depanmenlolslala Case Fr2olsu14u2 DEE commas manna/2912015
l,mgludbvlu1clall/Vayzn
FOIA 0mm
mumhu
suimnrmahngplm. clew mmhlnauau luiyzinn, and
Idvnnuc mslirm mum: clininml was mum! caswv;
nzndnl mdldun. (new Ammlm Aummulls alums
mqugsl pnhlic my. 5mg CREVl we, llgn cumulus Ignks Khamnd: quocumzms cuw unwind bum mullipk gusts. :22
www limfmclh gm. CREW: mum inch-den dammit! (clavingm exam
linignhall, lnlemn mu: mphmu, Fadznl annual. Oumwsmn wmyhiuu.
um: [hat mum-um, CREW uns miluin fur In: wlivcn
CREW also ask; chum mm: nmw mm: th maul beans:
CREW qlnlilmu mmmdn aflhznzws pumm sum, Nar lsx:
mm: Btp 40.19 ml, (nu 01.929) 0mm Appeals (or 1mm: ofthlumbln mum tmm mum Semriry m}. was vcpmnuuv: auodu rem anIMYOIA ItgishLivg himrymhizb Indicates mum Izpresalunvt mums modu lsm lawman bmdly; [iJl .smnm mum
Mmtumlv: ommws man broi lyxnklpmlbdxf Idula work mm. anypauan quantum whzdl mgulartypnbmu dkxanirmlu m/ommlm m};
mm. mum mlmay Irpnnqla 9/th new; 131 Cong. Rm,
slam (daily Sapl. an, was) (emphasis mm), and
CREW rodllmly mummy mm-am. mmmn lb; pub mm]
wly). Flux, CREW nhm mum, lemd mm. Wan. max
nouvul 33:71 pig; vuw: 2012. nnwnhsilueponslbglalmdcv npmuu
wnlalns Mam Informanon mm, wzmm agzwes and rms, nddiunn, CREW dummzms mm: under FOIA
and sir: hasnuived 2.237,le mum mwu lawman; mic Apr-1 .1qu
Stand, 2007. cazw puhluhtd mline nmlmu. 025mm
away has 15,564 sumcribm cmwcm pmvm mum; will) ngulal updms CREWI infommmn Lil: organization lam mama {Wm
mam mmplm ufplsl wwcm availzblc cnzw plums blag. cum; bloggl nglor rimwmuuy amt
Wuhixglnn puns and mum lxwxwanhy dcvnlnpmnnu ugavdmg gmmmm 21mm
and amupuan. mung, lawn! WWW; also mum
an: aim Emu mick: Indcummury nnmusc usuu CREW53IA-lg
5.665 pig; views (mm mm.
uncussmeo uepanmemmsme Case Frzmarmooz Dun commas Dale mans/2015
UNCLASS FIED Dapanmsnlmstau? Case Fizmarmmz Dan commas Dam mam/2015
gm: Vain nuarou omen
11th
7.;
Funny. cuw mum mummu Kym dun-1.: the mu: gavcmmnm 1nd mmp mm; mm: wan nmm kuppmg
luwn lbllinu. Rum mm. aganny wan alumni: more
kupmg mynmhilllins; :an Dunn: mmpxenmmmkiam mnpmrgmcmntnt
mimic; an: rum urn-mm and um: 019mm
mam UpFw Du! mm. Thou Ind cum availahlz mumsm publimim: imvidu, eshmm war/u
npmmive nflm mdii lulu 1h: POM. ynu quulinns abcm mi: mum furs-A pmlzlnms th requmnd mm, mm: (2H) ovum. Alm, ircREW: mum! far (a: gamed can. plus: comm immadincly vpon ranking sud: dmmm on.
Hammad nqmstzd (mm: mam-n... Cinun: Mponsihimy uni Emu: wmm Ey: Smell Suimasn, menn. .1; woos.
Sin Icly, wig-mm
cmxmm
Eudnmn
UNCLASS Depanmenlulsla CaserFFlzmsmmz Dec cn51m7e5 Dae 03/29/2015
UNCLASS FVED Depamuenmrsme Case F.2msamnz Dan: coelmszl Dene 08/29/2016
ommm, ,mmnmhnvu
RELEASE nu.
wxren suns nxsnum couxr
so: nxsrnxcr Cowman
cmss mum, 31.,
plaxnuns. Case no, 114519 (E65:
mum: sums 95MB cows,
Defendant.
mam ormxml
nus rreeam Infamaum ICE (mm) case berore
Cour: on- efendan: the Unwed Slates Peace Corps Motion
Dun-Asa or, the Alternative. fox Summary Judging-mt. For the
:Easnns Explainzd bglnu, the Motion memes Ml) ammo
and Manon Eur summery :udgmenr wnl amen
nsnxzn nemmm
Ylainziffs Charles human and mrscnecs are former Peace
Corps Volunteers. Both pxaanmze have been zdvmmtes Ear
stxangthenxng and mummy the Peace Corps; may have sewed the boards non-prb dtaanuauons suppemng returned
Feace Corps volunteers and ceezmea before Congress behalf current Fsace Coxys vexunneers, con-pl. avsr zme
uwcussmzo LLS Depanmsmofstate Cass st-UMUZ Do: No.CU61DaEZ1D-
UNCLASSIFIED Dapanmenm Stahvcaw Nn.Frzn1D14n2 not cosmahzw Dale Ila/29123167
:ma m/Jud tara tuerou hpru x5, anus, plslnnliis smatteu you request seeking
productaon, electron KarmaL, country-by-countfy
breakout the Peice Corps 2005 survey its Volunteers.
comm, The Peace carpa aahhaueagea the Lnfcmation
exaetea. but stated that nut avallable the (urinal:
[pnaaautsal asked for. Camp) Peace corps amed
plalnmlls that would :05: anywhere from approximately $550
sum for the P:a:e Corps search car and prodUC: (h:
xnfcmation, and that productron would not electrmic. 1a, 20-23 May 21, zoos, pxaahtam med appeal the Peace
Corps ueessaeaa regardma the document praduttian format and
costs 29, While the appeal was pehasaq. pxaiaurta were
approached Peace Corps starter who rammed plaintiffs that
the aauhtryhy-country bruakuut the 2an survey was
avaxlable, eaeatmme smut. )1. rue atauer emaneu
the Lnfomahon pxamtms, who then posted the
eeaeecorpawtxa weusrte. re. :1. .me 24. zoos. the hetahg
mreetnr the Peace carpa Hanagement emaued Ludaaa,
nataa that the inlaxmatmn taught avahlable
peaaecurpswski, and :ancludzd mean-z appear necessary to:
uncussxrlsn Depanmemoisiale Case Nu. F-zms uuuz Doc 5051mm use cam/2m
UNCLASSIFIED Us. Depanmenlnl sme case F-IOIB-OMEIZ pog No_CDE10421 Date mam/gm
yam Us; row
[the peace Corps] continue arait your {Equest Ear :hese. Deczmblr 15. mo, Ludlam summed second POIA request,
aaax sug 55ml the Peace Corps comprehensive survey the
Volunteers Ea: 2005 and 2010, [Including] the worldwide results
and the breakouts the result: cnuntry caumry and program program :ar each cam rrym Id. march 17, zen,
you attics: pxwxded aggregatad worldwide summary resuna
the 2009 and 2MB Annual Vuluntzer Surveys (INS but informed
Mr. Ludlam mat the indivmual cuuntry and prugrlm survey
results were Arnhem under Exemptions and spccxncany, the agency claimed Lne Lniomi ion sought was
Exempt from arscsoaura because was covered the
deliherazive process pnvuege, because Involved matters per5onal privacy
Mx. Ludlam appealed deciswn March ms, his
appeal. diam narrowed requesL arm: Volunteer
responses nopemended queaclans the
April 2:111, Earl Yates, Asaamasa Director fnt Management Peace was, xeleased Ludlam and 2010
results reg)una1 levelv saa muer Dec). 17, However.
Each Peace Coxps post has numher pragrama projectS
such educ on. health and agriculture, Defendant Motxnn nasmiaa for summary Judgmznc Def. naasv) Au.
Declaration panora Miller (vmuer Dec) 15.
UNCLASS FIED u.s Depanmemolsme Case Fezmsnunz Due mamaszt Dale us/zs/zma
UNCLASS FIED U.s Depanmemulsme Case Na. F-zmumnz Doc CDBID4321 D202 08/29/2016
sense m/Jud Vain xHaFOu
Yates denied his appeal for counzzyrbyrcountry and ymgxam-uy-
pragram {eapanszs, citxng same Exgmpmnns
elesnmss med actinn nugustil, 2m. snenensmg
only denxal the December 15. request, sncxcly
thereainer, the peace Cary: zeleased addinanl). infomstxan mam. about January :1, 2012, the Peace seeps
pun/mad Ludlam esgnmeen: paman or, the :Dunzzy-by-cauntry
and prcgrnm-by-program Avs results for and 2am Miller
Deal. The Peat: Corps canttnued withheld, Hhol: pm, Van-area: respnnses seven questions Avs
and :en questnms AVS Count:y>by-caunr.ry and
pxugzamrbyrprogrlm breakouts Pgbruary mm, {112
aezenuen: moved dxsmias, the enesneuue, for summary
Judgment. matmn rxpe for Courts deciuonv
xx. 57mm mum
A.Mnt1cm Dimmin-
Exhaustnm I): edmimstnnve xemedies cases
generally xequma nature mung suit [ederal court that agency has oppexcumy exemee its discretion and
expemse manner end make factual more support decislun Oglgsuy 0232: Amy, 529 51, (D.c. use) (overruled paxt other grounds). you requires requester exhaust admimsLIaLive xememee; when
UNCLASS FIED u.s DuwanmemnlSme Case mummeuz DocNo,CuEm4321 Dam ems/Ems
uNcmssmiD Depanmmovsme CaseNo.F-ZU18~OMUZ Du: No. 005104821 Damages/me
mmmwmww xhaFom
defendlnr. dxsputes plaxnnff has dune 50. ch: mdccex Fxopctly the subject motion under Rule leE) for
(snore state cum upon which relief can granted.
HAdalga Pod. aureou :nvesugauon. :44 P.3d use, use
mt. csr, 2003) Eumnlry ngmunt
Pursuant Federal Rule cxvu Procedure 55, summary
judgment ahnuld granted the mung party has Shawn mar
there are genome issues marerm and mm: the movmg
party enntled judgment nutter See m1. )1.
cu, 56; Celotex carp. Garrett. :25 (was):
wacethause mscric: columns, 299 939, 551 (no Cir.
1002). decemimng whether enulne issue (act exists,
the com must View all (acts 5.. the light most. favorable the
non-Wang parry, See Matsuahlca Exec. Indus. 25mm.
Rama Corp u.s 574, 531 [ISEGL mkewxse. xuhng
nrossmmnions Ear Bummary judgment, court shall grant:
summary judgment A7an one moving parties :nuzlzd judgmen: mutter law upon mtenal has that are no:
genuxnely d)5vutadr Cjtxzens fur Respam-mzrcy ems
Nash Dep Jusucs, 659 Supp, 2.1 mm:
may (tiung wands MEFErEun, 517 as, C):
)9751).
UNCLASSIFIED uvs Depanmemolsxale Case mowouoz on: Nu. cnamen comma/2512015
uNcmssmEu uepsnmsniolsme Case Hum-0mm Duc 5361mm Dam-0812912016
sns: gym: nuaFou FuIA
rm- requires egenciss sissioss s11 requested agency
records. 0.5.5. 552m. uniess one uins specific
senzutury exemptians nppnizs, 552m): designed
pierce tne usii ssninistrstive secrecy and open agency
action the iigne public scrutiny, new: Al: Force
Rose, u.s. 152. ssi (sitntions omittscn. Given the
WXAE broad dissiosurs psncy, the United states Supreme Ccurt consxsuenuly scntzd Fan sxsnptrons are narrowly
construed, wolf cu, 47: 37a. cir. 2907)
{quoting pep-t Juatxce John, U.s. (men.
Pams strong presumption (avur dissinsurs pisses
the burden [ht sgsnsy justify the uitnnoming ofany
requested documents. Dep scare Ray. ieu.
[1951: (citation omitted), The governnsnt may sstisty
burdzn establishing irs right wiUIhDJd information train
the publu: sub mtting appropriate declaracians and, where
necessary. )ndcx the Information thhhel see Vaughn
Roses, sm, men Ch. 1973). agencys davit assorisss [he justifications for withholding tns
inromation um. specizis sessii, demonstrates that the
intomstisn w.chheld-logically falls witnin the claimed
exemption, and not cantxadicted contrary evidence
UNCLASS FIED asssnmemolsme Case F-zms-cmoz Dan cummm Daismsxzs/zm
uNcmssxerD Depanmemuisme Case F-zmwmoz Doc cue1o az1 Bases/2912015
Ema: gym: Vain marou
record evidence (he aqzncys bud mun, men summiry
judgment warranted the basss the IEILdavu alone.
ACLU DepE the Defense 52a p.35 51:. [n.c. cu.
2mm,- sea {an agency yuscsnssusn invukxng you
exsmpuon suifxcxent appeaxs Jogxcal pnsusimew
unnsmsl citatmns omitted)
xxx nxscussm niumlslnl Plunhff xxxsshsrs
The Peace waps argues that plaintiff Paula unschszs must dxszlussed from this case hzcnusa she did not. tile Ch:
December 15, FOLK nq-uesn, Much the only request
issue (1115 lawsutt. DEE. Huts 878 The plaintiffs
not oppose defendant argument. Plaxntlifs Dypasxtxun
Marlon-to Dis/ 2.55 Eur Summary Judgment 575 P15,
Oppn) Accordingly, the defendant motion msmss
plaintiff Hirschafi own.
The Fumes also not dispute that the remaining
plainnrt, chsnss Ludlam, has properly exhausted hxs
admimsn auvs remedxes Accurdxngly, msmisssl
Muchoii doe; nut impact. the Court abi census:
case its merits.
UNCLASS napsnmsnmsme Case mumsmmz Dal: {3061mm Dana mam/2015
UNCLASSIFIED Depanmemovsxaxe Case Fezmaeounz Dar. 006104821 Dana 08(29/2016
me: m/Jud Vain neron Waiver threshold mutter. 91mm: arms that the Peace
Cums has uazved the rxght xnvake nxenpuone and
regarding vanhneld memes Ema: nne cuunuy-by-cuuntry and
pxbgrankhyrpxagtam breakouna (he 2an and Mrs.
plainuu clams waiver necnnse nne agency pxzvlously
disclosed neepnnees emeranunuy name: nnenmnn
the zone Voluntzar survzy, and (21 Peace corps leaders are
encouraged and da, share (h: 2009 and AVE xespcnses
with ether with 3013: Place Cur staff. P)s. Opp 3144.
Defendant, contrast. :antends thnt [he plaintif! cannot
aemonscrace that (ha responses me. 2003 and 2am surveys
match the respcnaee 200E surveys. thereiore. :ne Fcacc
Corps has not unwed any exempnam Def- Reply 21-25.
Put the reasons cussed below, the Cnuxt agrees Huh detenaen:
and finds tha: waiver uncured. Circuit. ch: public-dnmin doctxxne has emerged the annrnnn yiradxgm Eur evalua:1ng the newer
pecenml rom axzmptxon Under [the] yahlxcwiomain doctrine,
mated-15 nomny snnnnnzed from memes-m under you ins:
cnene protecLJ/e cloak once dxsclosed and prEserved
permanent puma record. Cantonz Reno. 1s: F.3d 55a, 554 cnr. ms) (cxtntians omitted). The 199m [Ins
decnrxne than where )nEamanan requeezed truly puhlxm
uNcmssttEo Depsnmenmvsme Case nmsmm Dan comm: Demos/2942015
umcmgsjrxzu U.S.De_p_anmemn15lae Case r-zmsowm Doc No,co 1m52 naxezua/zsvzma
maw edwluica waw damn
:nan enfoxcement exemptlun cam-m: [man its purposes.
Id. [citations nnuuad plaxnurr asscrting LhaK
incnmaudn naa been previously exacldaad bears the annual
burden poinmng apecmc information an: puhlxc damnin
that dnpucacns that belng .4chch Public cmzan 0211 szace, 39d, ctr 199:). Ellagatinn
asmuac meannaudn has been released no: sumcxenc. this case, plaxntiff waxvar Argument can; hecause
has not shown (m: the manna rEspDnaes match any infumdtion
already the nunasc dun-aim draws only that cne aucanona
canmnad the zoos and 2am Avs are swatancnlly ddcnaaaa1 the questions the zone survey, However, defendant
notes, 1: the responses the amaya that planning aaaka,
nu: questions. Def Reply :5. Cunsxdexxng ma: :na
responses later surveys were provided durexdn:
grew valunteexs, ragaxdnng LheLr experiences during
dxifatent unc periad, chc xeapanaea not adentxcal
chase provhied zoos. Certainly. (h: plaintiil has nut
demonstrared, uun spauncicy, that previous daacnaannc
duplicates wuhheld automation,
The {act cnac the Peace Cams encouraged readers the
surveys share mfamauan and other staff Cannot salvage
FlllntLEfs mun waxver. mm: agancy leaders may have
UNCLASS FIED Depanmenlurslzm Case FVZMGOMOZ anNo 906104321 Dana dang/2m
MNCLASSIFIED napanmam olS13e Case Fzmsmnnz Um: 005104521 Daie na/zslzma
nzmai Mia yarn JEFOM
disseminated the survgy results min the agency, the piaintise
has nut shown that Peace rps officials were authorized to,
am, release was 2mm survgy result: general puhllc
auteiae the agency see nusun Advocates 11.5. Dep
Justice, Supp, 26,91, (mu: 2am
Accordingly, the Court finds that the Peace Corps has not
waxvnd its right invoke Exempuuns and with respect
the wiehheia material. Exemption
Exampcion covers personnel and medical mes and sinus:
miss the d)sl:lasuze which wauld canstltute clearly
unwarranted xnvasian gersnnai privacy. use. 552(1)] 161 determination proper withholding undex Exemption proceeds two stages. First, the Mn: must decxde the JnEDmatxm aubjem: pretectien, specimenny, whether [he intamatien contained personnel, medical, sinusi- we, and
so, whether disclosure compromise aubscanua],
wppcsed minimis. privacy xnterest. signizitnnt
privacy interest inpiieatea, (and other Exempmun
applies), ran :emance eisciaaure,~ Nacl Assn Retimd Fed.
Employees garner, :79 p.21: :73, 1n.c. cir. mm. It,
the ether hand. sntstantiai privacy interest stake, the
Court must then weigh the pnvacy intereet nondiseiosure
uncusswtn Depanmemalsme Case Fezmsmmz Dec cnsmosm Daie 03/25/2015
UNCLASS FIED Depenmemovsme Case Nu. mmamsm Du: No.506104821 Dae Dane/201s
ens: wind Vain xHaFOu
seems: the puhlxc xnceres: the release records drums d=Letm1ne unerner, balance. axsclosute would work
clearly ununrrnnuee anasxon pexlonal prxvacy. Lepeneexer :5: cxr 1995: unearnel quotation
marks muttedl. The agency beats the euraen Dexsuade rne
rem that. rne :xcmpcion nppl)cs. mums Mm, 745
um. may
The Peace curpe argues men :xempnon applies three
rypes quesrisns :11 anus and 2am nvs. Tne cuur: wul
address them 111 mm. Fix-r, gunner Rating shalt Performance
The Peace Corps vuzhheld complete pnnial answers
sevsra) quesmns regarding staff perrnnnenee. Push,
urnnem rne Ansuzrs queemne rne zoos Avs survey end the 2010 survey These quesrmns ere rdenurnn, and ask
Haw smashed are ynu bath Ln: nemn csre received Ernm your
Pcnoks) [Peace Corps Memcel omeernv The Vulunteers can
pmme 511 posssbl: zespunsas all, Mmjmally. equately, Consxderably, ExceptionaDy and No: ueeam Unless otherwise noted csurc talus all facts regnrumq quesuons and wnhheld respenaes Iran the Defendant
Moreen mum: (Tame Human: Responses), Exluhi:
use; AVSY. snubs: (2010 we), Ind [Vaughn meek), well Flaxntxffs Dppnsxuon, Ezdublt (Chart Wuhheld
Responses).
UNCLASS FIED Depsnmemolsme case F~2maemm2 Dav: cuswmszt Dam OHIZWZGIS
UNCLASS FIED Depanmemarsme Case Fezmeeouoz Dec {206104521 Data oarzmms
Ema: m/Judpa Vain xnaFom
The Peace corps also withheld pamax answers eaenueaz
queeeeone mos Avsy and Avsy. rneee queeuone as):
Ha-I sacxshed are,yau men the fallmung suppatl manned
in>cnuncry peaee CarpavstaEEY ana pemxtced the mummy
responses: Not an, mnmany, em-ace annexdenexy,
Exceptionally and Nut ueee quzstiuns were then amen out
mto .eepaxaee eun-queeuene nan dxiferenL staff vesxtiona/
Euncluunn. these (can, the Peace Cnrps wgthhald responses four: Hedita), safety and seeuuey. sue Selection and
ppepanuen. and reemxcal spine
parcsel responses menucax questions (zou Avs} and [2010 AVS) were also withhcld. These questinns ask Haw
eauld yau pace yaur meepeezien em. pee: staff? and pem tted
:he responses ndequate we; Aden-:2. The quesuons
were braken separate suheq-ugsciuns four topics:
responslveness issueq, infomaclva content,
cumin. level dxscussxng issues, and Adequacy Visits/Visus yaut site. They were further braken hate ssparatc sub-
questions for 2191 csrreren: staff poemans. (has! me)
the peace Ontps vuthheld Kespanses in:
Country nueemx,
Fragrant: Training ospseep/subepegsanan Prngxam axmng
Cuerdmalar Assessace peace corps Director/Prugxsm neuegex,
Pcno Safety and Securxcy Commence, Tummy Manager,
UNCLASSWED Depenmemoes Cnss Mom man: cnmuaam Dam nuns/20
UNCLASS FIED ospsnmemevsqsze esse F.2msmau2 Dan 506104521 Dale us/gs/zuls
0mm swam wrom
Yxnally questions (2009 MS) and 120m Avs) ask
uhar. exeene your country Dareczur as. Vuluntzer issues
and concerns tnrcugh incezicnons uses Vulumzeets and pennies
responses Mor. all, Minimally, sseeussezy. Cunsidarably,
Completely/Exceytaanally. Second Type uue tium Inaenainve Ind
usenmmussq Conduct/Xurinlmenh
The yssee Corps psxuauy withheld ens answer questxun (Ava zoxulv This quzstinn asks whethzr Volunteer: [Hlav:
encountered xnsensxtive Garments nenavsor mused ypu based
your raw, echnxcuy, Ede, gender sexual anenunon Exam
any she renewing suurces Vs1unzeers mum respond Yes, use sgsnesme. The quesnxan separated into four
eseeasues yec ple whn ugh: have engaged such conduct.
The Peace Corps unseen responses for Eva essesszies-
nesclnenessay Family and can-nunuy members.
Respnnses quzstlnn (svs 2mm were also pazmally
withheld. Thas queseaon asks Volunteers xepurt Any
discrxmxnatiun/harassment they have encdmtexed. The question
Idantifies several Lypes discrxninnese 3924 anci-xnenesn,
assessney. gendex, sscisucsxor, :ehaious. sexual. unenusisn,
sexual (physsesu and sexual mezean. volunteers caula respond
with number times they (s) encouncersd that type
nasassnene/asscnmnauen. and repurted (he Please
UNCLASS FIED Dspanmunmrsme CaseNn.F-201E-n1