Skip to content

Judicial Watch • LAPPL Notice of Judgement

LAPPL Notice of Judgement

LAPPL Notice of Judgement

Page 1: LAPPL Notice of Judgement

Category:Legal Document

Number of Pages:5

Date Created:September 23, 2013

Date Uploaded to the Library:September 24, 2013

Tags:LAPD, Charles Beck, Terry Green, Harold Sturgeon, City of Los Angeles, Levine, Illegal Immigration


File Scanned for Malware

Donate now to keep these documents public!

  • demand_answers

See Generated Text   ˅

Autogenerated text from PDF

IO~UI-J=-
 HAROLD STITRGEON,
RICHARD LEVINE, ESQ. (SBN 91671)
BRIAN ROSS, ESQ, (SBN 273991)
SILVER, I-IADDEN, SILVER, WEXLFR LEVINE
1428 Second Street, Suite 200
R0. Box 2161
Santa Monica, 90407-2161 I0) 393-1486 (Telephone)
(310)395-5801(FaX)
Attorneys for Plaintiff Los Angeles Police mtecl:iveI.e21gue
SUPERIOR COURT THE STATE CALIFORNIA
FOR TI-LE COUNTY LOS ANGELES
LOS ANGELES POLICE PRO IECTIVE
LEAGUE,
Case No. 483052
(Consolidated with Case No. BC484190)
Plaintiff, [Assigned Hon. Terry Green, Dept. 14]
NOTICE ENTRY JUDGMENT
CITY LOS ANGELES. municipal
corporation, CHARLES BECK, Chief
Police, City ofLos Angeles. and DOESI
through 20. inclusive,
Defendants.
Plaintiff,
CITY LOS AIVGELES, al. ALL PARTIES AND THEIR COUNSEL RECORD:
NOTICE HEREBY GIVEN that the Judgment i.n the above-entitled matters was
entered the Ilonorable Terry Green September 23, 2013 Department the Los geles County Superior Court. Judgment was entered favor PlainLiJ1Los Angeles
Police Protective League and Harold Sturgeon and against Defendants City Los Angeles
NOTICE ENTRY .TUDGMENI
ELSE
.._.#> ->_-
omxlos
and Charles Beck and inlerveners Voice and Coalition for Humane Imn1igmm.< Rights Los
Angeles. true and correct copy said Judgment attached hereto.
Dated: 2013 SILVFR, HADDEN, SILVER, WEXLER LEVINE
By:
RICHARD LEVINE
Attorneys for Plaintiff
Los Angeles Police Protective League
NOTICE ENTRY UDGMENT LEAGUE,
couronuen cow
s..5 3.;fclr l:u %3i:l:aiii m:a Anmalas
SEP 2013
Sham ner. Bcacuma Otticarlaerk Jaannlue Lorenz. Depulv
pt; 
SUPERIOR COURT THE STATE CALIFORNIA THE COUNTY LOS ANGELES
LOS ANGELES POLICE PROTECTIVE Case No. 433052
(Consolidated with Case No. BC484l90)
Plafnti [Assig-nedtn Hon. etry Green, Dept. 14}
[PROP ED] JUDGMENT
CITY LOS ANGELES, municipal
corporation, CHARLES BECK, Chief
Police, City ufLos Angeles, and DOES]
through 20, inclusive,
Defendants.
HAROLD STURGEON,
Plaintiff,
CITY LOS ANGELES. al. efendants.
vx/VUVvvvvvvvgvvvvvvgvvvvvvuv
The Motions for Summary Judgment the above-entitled matter came regularly [or
11:.-axing August 12, 2013 8:45 am, Department before the Honorable Terry Green.
The Motions for Summary Judgment were led P1ain1ifl Los Angeles Police Protective
League, Plaintiff Harold Smrgmu, Defendants City Los Angeles and Charlie Beck, and
JU])(I%4Il-INT
 xftl )3H
qoxuu Section 14602.6 not interchangeable with provisions Section 22651 (p).
lnterveners Voice and Coalition for Humane lnnnigrants Rights Los Angeles. Richard
Levine Esq. Silver, Iladden, Silver, Wexler Levine appeared for Plaintiff Los Angeles
Police Protective League. Paul Orfanedes appeared for Plai.ntilIHamld Sturgeon. Gerald
Sate, Deputy City Attorney appeared for Defendants City Los Angelcs and Charlie Beck,
Chief Police for the City Lns Angeles. Michael Kaufnmn appeared for lnterveners
Voice and Coalition for Humane lnmnigrants Rights Los Angeles.
The Court, having considered the Motions for Summary Judgment, pertinent legal
authorities, those matters which the Court may take judicial notice, and argument ofcournel,
granted the Motions for Suinniary Judgment Plaintiffs Los Angeles Police Protective ,eagne 
and Harold Sturgeon and denied the Motions for Siurnnary Judgment Defendants City
Los Angeles and Charlie Beck and lnterveners Voice and Coalition for Humane lnnnigrants
Rights Los Angeles, Tl-lEREFORJ*:L ADJ UDGED THAT: Pursuant the Cou.tt order granting Plaintiff Los Angeles Police Protective
League Motion for Summary Judgment, Plaintiff Los Angeles Police Protective League
entitled judgment the First Cause Action Plaintiffs First Amended Complaint for
Declaratory Relief Speci cally, the Court hereby udieially determines and declares: Special Order No. preempted Vehicle Code Section and
 nsttat the legislative ohjective uniform statewide impountlment regulations respecting
vehicles driven unlicensed drivers;
l3. Special Order No. contravenes! the statutory autl1nri7ati0n and
legislative intent vesting the authority peace officer impound vehicle driven
speci categories unlicensed drivers; and The discretionary authority officer impound vehicle under Pursuant the Couifs order granting Plaintiff Los Angeles Police rohective l.eague Motion for Summary Judgment, Pluintifflms Atigeles Police Protective
League entitled judgment the Second Cause Action llaintifts First Atuentled
JUD(j)MENT
2;:
Complaint for lnjuuctivc Relief. This Court therefore issues Permanent Injunction ordering,
restraining and enjoining Defendants and their agents. servants and employees and
representatives from enforcing Special Order No. Pursuant tlie-Courfs order granting Plaintiff Ilarold Sturgeoifs Motion
for Summary udgment, Plaintiff Harold Sturgeon entitled judgment the First
Cause Action Plaintiff Sturgeon Complaint for Declaratory and lnjunetive Relief.
Speci cally, the Court hereby judicially determines and declares that Special Order No.
conflicts with the provisions the California Vehicle Code. including California Vehicle
Code Sections 14602.6 and 14607.6, governing the impounding vehicles driven
 unlicensed drivers and therefore ultra vires under Vehicle Code Section preempted
the Vehicle Code, and unlawful and void. Pursuant die Co1.n*t order granting Plaintiff Harold Sturgeoifs Motion
for Summary Judgment, Plaintiff Harold Sturgeon entitled judgment the Second
Cause Acfion Pl2uutill Complaint for lnjuuctive Relief. This Court therefore issues
Permanent lnjunetion ordering, restraining and enjoining Defendants and their agents,
servants and employees and representatives liom expending taxpayer funds taxpayer-
Iinzuroed resources, including their own time the time other L/LPD cers, employees, oflieials, enforce, maintain, otherwise carry out Special Order No. Plaintiifs Los Angeles Police Protective League and Harold P.SLurgeon may
file Mntzions for At.torney Fees against Defendants City Les Angeles and Charlie Beck,
 Chief Police pursuant duly noticed Motion. the prevailing parties, Plaintiffs Los Angeles Police Protective League and
Harold Sturgeon are entitled costs incurred prosecuting this action puts ant 
 
II16H1Ur2Lt1Cll.1D1 costs.
Dated:
 
uhle Terry Green
gfoflhe Superior_lCyn_urt
 )I)QNIENT