Judicial Watch Seeks Federal Court Injunction against Secret Service for Records of Obama and VIP Security Costs for Travel
NOVEMBER 24, 2015
Agency Ignored 19 Judicial Watch FOIA Requests
(Washington, DC) – Judicial Watch announced today that it filed a lawsuit in the U.S. District Court for the District of Columbia against the U.S. Secret Service for failing to respond to 19 Judicial Watch Freedom of Information Act (FOIA) requests for security-related expenses related to travel by Barack Obama and other VIPs. The Secret Service has not responded to any of the 19 FOIA requests since July 21, 2014. The FOIA lawsuit, filed on November 10, asks the court to enjoin the Secret Service from continuing to withhold responsive documents from Judicial Watch. (The Secret Service is a component of the Department of Homeland Security.) (Judicial Watch v. U.S. Department of Homeland Security (No. 1:15-cv-01983)). The lawsuit was assigned to U.S. District Court Judge Richard J. Leon.
For years, Judicial Watch has regularly monitored expenditures of U.S. Government funds by the president, members of the first family, and other VIPs receiving Secret Service protection.
FOIA requests to the U.S. Air Force and other agencies enabled Judicial Watch to determine that, to date, the total known travel expenses for various trips by the Obamas and Bidens are currently $70,563,336.75.
But the extraordinary lack of cooperation by the Secret Service has prevented Judicial Watch from gathering complete records of taxpayer-funded, VIP travel. These Secret Service records typically include records of expenses incurred for ground transportation, lodging, meals, and other related costs, as well as the accompanying Secret Service details. The lawsuit details:
Since July 21, 2014, Plaintiff has submitted 19 travel-related FOIA requests to the Secret Service as part of Plaintiffs on-going monitoring of federally-funded, VIP travel. All of the requests were identical or nearly identical but for the name of the VIP and the date and/or destination of the travel. Plaintiffs requests sought: “All records concerning use of U.S. Government funds to provide security and/or any other services to [name of VIP] and any other companions on their [date] trip to [location].”
The Secret Service has not made a determination on a single, travel-related FOIA request served by Plaintiff since July 21, 2014.
Judicial Watch previously sued the Secret Service five times between 2012 and 2014 for security related information on presidential and VIP travel. Prior litigation and other FOIA requests resulted in a number of details about security costs of trips to New York for a “date night” ($11,648.17), a 2013 trip to Africa ($2,189,727.60), a 2013 adventure to Ireland ($251,161.86), and 2014 fundraising trip to Denver ($200,383.70).
Judicial Watch asserts that the Secret Service has “a policy and practice of violating FOIA” requirements, Judicial Watch attorneys are asking the court to enjoin the Secret Service from continuing to withhold the requested records and other information from Judicial Watch for 19 current requests.
Prior examples of Judicial Watch FOIA requests that gathered travel cost information include:
- A February and March 2015 golf and fundraising trip which cost taxpayers $4,436,245.50 in travel expenses alone;
- A June 2015 trip by Michelle Obama to the UK and Italy which cost taxpayers $240,495.67 in travel expenses alone;
- A March 2014 trip by Michelle Obama to China which cost taxpayers $360,000 in travel expenses alone;
- An April 2015 single day trip to the Florida Everglades for Earth Day which cost taxpayers $866,615.40 in travel expenses alone;
- And a February 2015 weekend ski trip by Michelle Obama to Aspen, Colorado, which cost taxpayers $57,000 in travel expenses alone.
“Rarely does Judicial Watch seek an injunction under FOIA, but the Secret Service has ignored a record 19 Freedom of Information requests on Obama and other presidential-level travel,” said Judicial Watch President Tom Fitton. “The FOIA requests seek access to records about taxpayer dollars expended on the extravagant and often unnecessary travel enjoyed by the President, his family members, and others receiving Secret Service protection. We have little doubt the Secret Service, which is already mired in controversy, is covering up embarrassing numbers about the costs of security for Barack Obama’s vacation and political fundraising trips.”
List of 19 FOIA Requests for Security Costs Ignored By the Secret Service
|No.||Date of Request||Date of Acknowledgment Letter||Tracking Number||Further Communication||VIP and Travel Date and/or Location|
|1||July 21, 2014||August 8, 2014||20140856||No||Pres. Obama’s July 17, 2014 Trip to New York, NY|
|2||July 28, 2014||August 8, 2014||20140853||No||Pres. Obama’s July 2014 Trip to Seattle, WA, San Francisco, CA, and Los Angeles, CA|
|3||August 25, 2014||October 20, 2014||20141036||No||Pres. Obama’s August 2014 Trip to Martha’s Vineyard, MA|
|4||September 2, 2014||February 9, 2015||20150067||No||Former Pres. Carter’s August 2014 Trip to Detroit, MI|
|5||September 2, 2014||November 8, 2014||20150066 and 20150067||No||Pres. Obama’s August 29, 2014 to September 1, 2014 Trips to Westchester, NY and Providence, RI|
|6||September 19, 2014||November 14, 2014||20150170||February 9, 2015||Vice Pres. Biden’s September 17, 2014 Trip to Iowa|
|7||September 19, 2014||November 14, 2014||20150171||February 9, 2015||Vice Pres. Biden’s May 9, 2014 Trip to South Carolina|
|8||October 20, 2014||November 6, 2014||20150107 and 20150217||December 1, 2014||Pres. Obama’s October 9-10, 2014 Trip to Los Angeles, CA|
|9||January 5, 2015||February 3, 2015||20150439||No||Pres. Obama’s December 2014 to January 2015 Trip to Honolulu, HI|
|10||February 18, 2015||March 16, 2015||20150560||No||Pres. Obama’s February 2015 Trip to Palm Springs, CA|
|11||February 23, 2015||March 16, 2015||20150564||No||Pres. Obama’s February 19, 2015 Trip to Chicago, IL|
|12||March 13, 2015||March 24, 2015||20150740||No||Pres. Obama’s March 12-13, 2015 Trip to Los Angeles, CA|
|13||March 16, 2015||April 2, 2015||20150759||No||First Lady Michelle Obama’s March 2015 Trip to Los Angeles, CA|
|14||March 30, 2015||April 29, 2015||20150815||No||Pres. Obama’s March 28-29, 2015 Trip to Palm City, FL|
|15||April 23, 2015||May 8, 2015||20150875||No||Pres. Obama’s April 23, 2015 Trip to Everglades Nat’l Park, FL|
|16||June 22, 2015||No||None||No||First Lady Michelle Obama’s June 2015 Trip to the United Kingdom and Italy|
|17||June 22, 2015||No||None||No||Pres. Obama’s June 18-21, 2015 Trip to California|
|18||July 23, 2015||August 31, 2015||20151283||No||Pres. Obama’s July 17-20, 2015 Trip to New York, NY|
|19||August 24, 2015||September 28, 2015||20151450||No||Pres. Obama’s August 2015 Trip to Martha’s Vineyard, MA|